메뉴 건너뛰기

XEDITION

등업게시판

Porn industry said Texas law violates US Constitution



Policymakers concerned about effects of porn on minors



Lower court allowed age-verification to take effect

By Andrew Chung

WASHINGTON, June 27 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court is expected to rule on Friday in a challenge on free speech grounds to a Texas law that requires pornographic websites to verify the age of users in a case testing the legality of state efforts to keep minors from viewing such material online.

A trade group representing adult entertainment performers and companies appealed a lower court's decision allowing the Republican-led state's age-verification mandate, finding that it likely did not violate the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment safeguard against government abridgment of speech.

The Texas measure is one of 24 similar ones enacted around the United States, primarily in Republican-governed states, with some set to take effect in the months ahead, according to the Free Speech Coalition, which challenged the law.

The law requires websites whose content is more than a third "sexual material harmful to minors" to have all users submit personally identifying information verifying they are at least age 18 to gain access.

The case tested the limits of state powers to protect minors from explicit materials deemed by policymakers to be harmful to them with measures that burden the access of adults to constitutionally protected expression.

Supreme Court precedents have protected access by adults to non-obscene sexual content on First Amendment grounds, including a 2004 ruling that blocked a federal law similar to the Texas measure. If the 2004 precedent prevents Texas from enforcing its law, then it should be overruled, the state argued, noting how the digital landscape has changed dramatically in the two decades since.

The coalition, a trade association of adult content performers, producers and distributors, as well as companies that run pornographic websites including Pornhub.com, xnxx.com, xvideos.com and Brazzers.com, argued that online age verification unlawfully stifles the free speech rights of adults and exposes them to increasing risks of identity theft, extortion and data breaches.

Some sites like Pornhub blocked access entirely in states with age-verification laws.

Steps such as content-filtering software or on-device age verification would better protect minors while respecting the rights of adults, according to the challengers. During Jan. 15 arguments in the case, the justices voiced worries about the pervasiveness of pornography online and the ease with which minors are able to access it. Conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett, the mother of school-age children, noted that minors can get online child porn through cellphones, tablets, gaming systems and computers, and noted that there has been an "explosion of addiction to online porn."

But some of the justices also expressed concern over the burdens imposed on adults to view constitutionally protected material, debating whether the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals should have applied a stricter form of judicial review to the Texas law than the one it actually used that gave deference to legislators.

U.S. District Judge David Alan Ezra issued a preliminary injunction in 2023, blocking the law. The 5th Circuit ruled in 2024 that the plaintiffs were unlikely to succeed in their First Amendment challenge to the age-verification requirement, lifting Ezra's injunction on that provision. The 5th Circuit upheld Ezra's injunction against another provision requiring websites to display "health warnings" about viewing pornography. The Supreme Court last year declined to halt enforcement of the law while the case proceeded.

(Reporting by Andrew Chung; Editing by Will Dunham)

번호 제목 글쓴이 날짜 조회 수
공지 esky에 오신걸 환영합니다. 관리자 2024.12.09 33
4165 What Are The Categories From The American Music Awards? Clinton21416662397 2025.07.12 0
4164 Rats And Mice Control In Your Home JuanSumsuma750794 2025.07.12 3
4163 Make Cash Money For Surveys With The Help Of Free Paid Online Surveys DemetraSharkey8 2025.07.12 3
4162 Answers About Child Support PLVJoe937384880 2025.07.12 0
4161 20 Myths About Mighty Dog Roofing : Busted... Stepanie36269524 2025.07.12 0
4160 Answers About Australia KateLort498572269432 2025.07.12 0
4159 Усильте Позиции Сайта Быстро И Эффективно! PerryGalvin990981 2025.07.12 0
4158 Securing The House: A History Of Casino Protection Raphael23I870201 2025.07.12 0
4157 The Pros And Cons Of Mighty Dog Roofing ... PearlHammett18518 2025.07.12 0
4156 Wednesday's Major League Linescores DorcasNielson9397 2025.07.12 0
4155 Answers About Centipedes LarueMcElhone06771 2025.07.12 0
4154 Answers About Dresses And Skirts JustineGuidi0402 2025.07.12 0
4153 How To Obtain Bios: Some Simple Steps DelmarNeace42677694 2025.07.12 3
4152 What Is This Thing Called Google X? Pearl0754500063120 2025.07.12 0
4151 10 Things Most People Don't Know About Mighty Dog Roofing ... GwendolynCalloway90 2025.07.12 0
4150 Winning At Blackjack: An Introduction To Strategy PamelaKinsey46372 2025.07.12 0
4149 How To Win Big In The Mighty Dog Roofing Industry... ElviaToombs4254 2025.07.12 0
4148 Everything You've Ever Wanted To Know About Mighty Dog Roofing ... AlbertinaOsburn7865 2025.07.12 0
4147 Answers About ABBA ZacheryNankervis 2025.07.12 0
4146 TULSA, Okla NellSpeer102139627 2025.07.12 0
위로